Unitalen Represents TATA in Complete Reversal of Second-Instance Rulings for Cases of Cancellation of Trademarks for Non-use for Three Consecutive Years, Successfully Cancelling Multiple TATA Copycat Trademarks
Time:2026-08-17  Source:

Case Brief

The third party, Suzhou Boshilong Smart Home Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Boshilong"), had registered multiple TATA copycat trademarks, including "TATAAQM", "TATAZN", and "TATAZTJJ", covering various classes of goods, including Class 6, Class 9, and Class 11. Unitalen represented the Principal in filing cancellation applications with the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA) against the aforementioned trademarks on the grounds of non-use for three consecutive years.

Boshilong submitted evidence of use, including trademark license documents, licensees' sales contracts, bank receipts, and sales invoices. After examination, the CNIPA issued a decision on the review of cancellation, determining that the evidence on record could prove that the disputed trademarks had been subjected to open, genuine, and lawful commercial use on the approved goods during the designated period, and decided to uphold the registration of the disputed trademarks. The court of first instance also held that the sales contracts and invoices submitted by Boshilong identified both the goods and the disputed trademarks and were sufficient to prove the sale of goods bearing the disputed trademarks during the designated period. The court further determined that the use reached a satisfactory quantity and scale and was not token use, thereby upholding the registration of the disputed trademarks.

Dissatisfied with the judgment of first instance, the Principal filed an appeal with the Beijing High People's Court.

In its judgment of second instance, the Beijing High People's Court determined that the evidence of use submitted by the third party "could not exclusively point to the disputed trademarks and did not conform to common business practices"; thus, it was insufficient to prove genuine, lawful, and effective commercial use of the disputed trademarks on the approved goods during the designated period. Consequently, the court canceled multiple TATA copycat trademarks registered by the third party.

Case Significance

The present case clarifies the standard of proof for trademark use in cases of "cancellation of trademarks for non-use for three consecutive years". The judgment of the second instance has explicitly pointed out that when contracts and invoices simultaneously contain multiple different trademarks, and when the number of trademarks far exceeds the quantity of goods, making it impossible to exclusively point to the disputed trademarks, such contracts and invoices shall not be deemed satisfactory evidence to prove actual commercial use of the disputed trademarks. This adjudication standard serves as a significant reference for regulating the scope of evidence review in cases involving "cancellation of trademarks for non-use for three consecutive years".

In addition, the present case is one of batch-cancellation cases filed against the TATA copycat trademarks registered under the name of Boshilong. Boshilong had registered multiple copycat trademarks similar to the well-known brand "TATA". The evidence of use submitted by Boshilong in each case was identical and questionable in content, reflecting obvious characteristics of token use. The victory in the present case marks a ruthless crackdown on trademark registration practices lacking genuine use intent, safeguarding the healthy trademark registration order.